10

I suspect it's leftover from before the woodworking site launched, but given that woodworking does exist, the tour for this site shouldn't encourage users to post questions which would be more suited for another site.

On a related note, perhaps it would be helpful to point out other SE sites where questions that are off-topic here would be on-topic. For instance, gardening & landscaping for landscaping, arts & crafts for hobby projects, etc.

help page

1
  • 1
    Looking at the edit history for the tour, that text pre-dates the help center, i.e. it would have come from the old FAQ at /faq which now redirects to the tour. Probably time we updated it.
    – Niall C. Mod
    Nov 30 '16 at 21:00
9

Per the usual division between them, Carpentry belongs here. Though "finish carpentry" starts to get fuzzy, and when you get to the point of built-in furnishings others fuzzier still. It's really more a matter of attitude and context than technique... but it's real, and it affects both where people will look and where they will find the best advice.

If it has to be permanently attached to the house to be stable, it probably belongs here no matter how pretty the woodwork. Putting poly on a flourishing improvement.

If it is just sitting on the floor, it probably belongs in Woodworking even if it's thrown together from white-wood dimensional lumber. Putting poly on a table is woodworking.

If it is hanging on French cleats, I can argue it either way...

2

Ask about...

  • Rough and finish carpentry.

Don't ask about...

1

I recently asked a woodworking question, and got told to ask it on woodworking.SE (which is where the link points to now).

So, the removal the bullet in the FAQ saying that we can ask questions about woodworking should really have already happened yesterday.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .